Skip to Content
Talkhouse home
Talkhouse home
Film

To Protest or Not to Protest

Actress Irene Sofia Lucio on the question that starring in Liberation on Broadway during the time of ICE raids has forced her to reckon with.

Last week, I did a talkback for Liberation on Broadway. A woman asked, “Given the play and the current political climate, do you feel hope or despair when it comes to the present moment?

It’s a great question.

Liberation deals with a Women’s Liberation Consciousness Raising group, from 1970 to 1973. It’s a few years after the assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert Kennedy. Nixon is being investigated for Watergate. There are protests about the Vietnam War, and the Civil Rights and Women’s Liberation movements are rampant. The National Guard has been mobilized to suppress protestors, and innocent people are getting killed in the crossfire.

It’s no coincidence that Liberation has felt more timely and urgent than ever.

Susannah Flood and Irene Sofia Lucio in the Broadway production of Liberation. (Photo by Little Fang.)

The character I play, Isidora, is an Italian immigrant and embodies the group’s strength. She gets the women to take to the streets in protest. Every night, I utter the play-by-play of what the group is to do: “First we shut down traffic with the banner … Then we go from car to car and we give them the fliers …”

And after all of what’s been happening in the news … I get the feeling I’m telling the audience what we have to do.

But then Lizzie, the narrator, interjects: “We could get arrested. We could get shot.”

And now … I have to pause before answering: “You’re not getting shot.”

I am writing this shortly after Renee Good was shot and killed, and just a few days after a five-year-old was detained and used as bait to arrest his father – with a pending and legal asylum application.

We are all bombarded by news like this, but I feel like I’m experiencing the news cycle particularly viscerally. As a mother, these stories just hit harder. I’m also a Latina and child of immigrants and political asylum seekers, plus my character in Liberation is an immigrant.

Irene Sofia Lucio with her son Hugo. (Photo courtesy Irene Sofia Lucio.)

Which brings me back to the question from the talkback: Do I feel hope or despair? I’m still trying to figure that out. What I can say is the play does an excellent job of showcasing women’s lives as a historical continuum. We are invited to take a hard look at our mothers, their lives, and what they fought so hard for us to get. We can now buy a home, have credit cards, play sports professionally. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg. For a while there, we even had autonomy over our own bodies.

As I look back at the historical continuum and see how far these women marched, it also forces me to look at my own place in that continuum. I am now raising my son, who’s about to turn two. What is my role in helping him shape his world, his view on women, on immigrants, on presidents, given our reality?

That’s where I come in, right?

What kind of mom is my child seeing if I stay indoors when all of this is happening?

While I can’t say for certain whether I feel hope or despair, what I can say is that I know I have a role to play in this continuum, both for myself and for my son. I can’t be a daughter of a woman from the ’70s and a mother of the next generation and do nothing. My feelings may matter less than my actions.

Though to be honest, what I really feel is overwhelming fear. I want to be a role model, I want to show up for my community, and I also don’t want to get shot. My kid needs me.

Irene Sofia Lucio celebrates Pride Month with her son Hugo and husband, Jorge Marquez San Martin. (Photo courtesy Irene Sofia Lucio.)

So … what this moment and this play is asking of me, of all of us, is to be brave. Brave in a way that makes us join history. Asking you and me to go out, and knowing that there is power in numbers, because they can’t take all of us. To hold the line. To link arms and march toward the future we want for the children coming behind us. I’ve never felt more urgency and more fear at once. But Isidora is a brave character and I hope her bravery is catching – for me and for the audience – inspiring us to take action.

And maybe I’ve somehow finally understood the stakes of protesting in the 1970s. Of what our parents did. Maybe it’s taken me this long to understand how brave they really were. And for that, I am forever grateful. My hope is that this experience will embolden me to borrow from their bravery for the battles we have to fight now. To be the person I need to be, for myself and for my son.

Featured image shows Betsy Aidem, Kristolyn Lloyd, Irene Sofia Lucio, Adina Verson, Audrey Corsa and Susannah Flood in the Broadway production of Liberation; photo by Little Fang.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

Related Stories

Nobody’s Ever Asked Me That: Abel Ferrara

The legendary writer-director opens up about everything from Buddhism and bad acid trips to social media addiction and sobriety.

The Stories We Invent Before We Have Language

Rhythm is a Dancer’s writer-director-star Lauren Caster on donor conception, language and a lifelong search for belonging.

July 17, 2026

What I Learned Directing My First Franchise Film

Kimmy Gatewood on how she thought big and gained expertise on the fly while helming her new movie, Descendants: Wicked Wonderland.

July 16, 2026

On Being Fired

Actor and singer Alicia Witt, whose David Lynch-inspired album Between Heaven and Earth is now on preorder, shares a universal experience.

July 13, 2026

When Art Finally Catches Up to You

Filmmaker Zachary Ray Sherman on making his debut feature for $10K, shelving it for eight years, and finally understanding what it was all about.

July 10, 2026

What I Learned Making The Land That Time Forgot (and Mockbuster!) in Six Days

Director Anthony Frith pulls back the curtain on the insane experience of making a film for the Asylum, as captured in his new film, Mockbuster.

July 9, 2026