Skip to Content
Talkhouse home
Talkhouse home
Music

Talkhouse Playlist: Holiday Picks from Band of Merrymakers

Find out what Christmas song made this supergroup cancel their USA Today subscription.

Holiday supergroup Band of Merrymakers (made up of Sugar Ray's Mark McGrath, Better than Ezra's Kevin Griffin, Neon Trees' Tyler Glenn, American Idol/Rock of Ages' Constantine Maroulis and songwriter Sam Hollander) head out on tour this year to spread some holiday cheer. To celebrate, Hollander put together this playlist of classic and underrated Christmas music. So get into the holiday mood and catch Band of Merrymakers live this December! Select dates here:

12/1 New York, NY @ BB King's
12/2 Morristown, NJ @ Mayo PAC
12/3 Ridgefield, CT @ Ridgefield Playhouse
12/15 Los Angeles, CA @ The Troubadour

–Dave Lucas, Talkhouse Marketing Manager

Band of Merrymakers – "A Very Merry Medley"
Duh!

August Darnell – "Christmas on Riverside Drive"
Deep cuts. This is that snow-blown New York City shit! Both funky and festive.

The Brady Bunch – "Frosty the Snowman"
Nothing says Christmas like Cindy Brady lisping her way through this holiday chestnut.

Vince Guaraldi Trio – "Skating"
Sounds like a piping hot chocolate in Central Park with December mirth in the air.

RUN-DMC – "Christmas in Hollis"
OMG! An ill reindeer!!

Wizzard – "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Everyday"
I triple dog dare you to watch this wacky YouTube clip. It’s musical spiked egg nog.

June Christy – "The Merriest"
The Merrymakers approve on title alone.

Paul McCartney – "Wonderful Christmastime"
In 2014, the USA Today named it the worst Christmas song ever. In 2014, we effectively cancelled our USA Today subscription. This is a jam!

The Carpenters – "It Came Upon a Midnight Clear"
That acapella intro though! Truly the mecca of glee club perfection.

The Waitresses – "Christmas Wrapping"
Merry Christmas. Merry Christmas. Couldn't miss this one this year.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

Related Stories

Mood Board: Sari Lightman’s The Way I Saw You

The LA folk artist on how Eve Babitz, the Holiday Inn in Encinitas, Big Foot, and more inspired her new record.

July 17, 2026

Alex Zhang Hungtai and Andrew Thomas Huang Tend to Old Wounds

The artists talk ancestry rituals, the unconscious, and more.

Daisy the Great and Harmony Tividad Are Freaky With It

Kelley Dugan and Mina Walker tell Harmony how the band started with a Pinter scene, their love of musical theater, and more.

A Nuanced Analysis of AI Music

Adam Schatz (Landlady) offers an even-keeled take on Suno's new grant for artists.

July 15, 2026

Nobody’s Ever Asked Me That: Stephin Merritt

A giddily fun and freewheeling conversation with the musical mastermind behind the Magnetic Fields.

Joshua Bailey and Brendan Canty on the Punk Origins of Stolen Kingdom

The filmmaker and the Fugazi drummer/composer talk the new documentary, and more.

July 14, 2026