Skip to Content
Talkhouse home
Talkhouse home
Film

I Put All My Best Ideas into the Movie Itself, So Don’t Expect Much From This Essay

Rachel Wolther, whose new film The French Italian is now streaming, shares the very best (remaining) material she has about her movie!

10:00 AM EST on November 4, 2025

One of the weird things about making a movie is that while it seems to me pretty obvious the whole thing is a large, complicated exercise in self-expression, as a filmmaker I am constantly called upon to talk about my film. The very thing I made to explain myself, I now must attempt to explain (again). I mean, can't you just watch the trailer and get the gist?

HOWEVER, I am a big ham who secretly wishes I were a stand up comedian, and I can't resist any opportunity to speak into a microphone. So as part of the release of my new film, The French Italian, I agreed to do 16 Q&As over a period of two weeks to support screenings in New York and Los Angeles. Here's how it went.

Favorite Question: “Can you talk more about the visual style of the film, and the use of wipes and split screens?” What a nice softball question, because it gave me a chance to talk about the wonderful artists who made it happen. The look of the movie is the result of collaboration with cinematographer Charlotte Hornsby, costume designer Nell Simon and production designer Kit Sheridan as well as makeup/hair artist Dawn Campbell. We had so much fun playing with color in every scene, telling the visual story to compliment all the jokes. And the split screens are a reference to my favorite Doris Day movie Pillow Talk.

Least Favorite Question: “Do you think the main characters, Doug and Valerie, actually have a good relationship?” I'm sorry, I am not a couples therapist. I can’t, like, psychoanalyze my fictional characters. I was trying to write complicated, funny, semi-realistic humans who would be interesting to watch as they repeatedly affirm each other into mistakes, so as to motivate the plot. They are not meant to be role models.

Catherine Cohen and Aristotle Athari in Rachel Wolther's The French Italian.

But also, yes, because I basically just wrote myself and my partner exactly the way we talk to each other, and we’re doing just fine, thank you.

Most Frequently Asked Question: “Where did you get the idea for this movie?”

Honestly, a lot of the time I interpreted this as, “Why did you make me watch this?” but that might be my own insecurity. It's probably just an innocuous starter question.

Second Favorite Question: “Tell me about the music in the film?” I am so proud of the original score by Simon Hanes and I love talking about how he managed to wrangle a string quartet to record the score for the finale live in the studio while the scene played on the monitor, just like they did for The Phantom Menace.

Highlight of the Run: Unprompted, a semi-famous filmmaker whose movie restoration I had just seen at the IFC Center came to the screening and introduced herself after the show. And she said she liked the movie!

Rachel Wolther (center) directing Catherine Cohen and Aristotle Athari during the making of The French Italian.

Low Point of the Run: The lights came up for the Q&A on a weeknight show and there were only two people in the audience. One was my friend Sharon. I had to tell the moderator (the hilarious Spike Einbinder) that they could leave. Sharon did stick around for a few minutes and asked me some questions, so that was nice at least.

Most Adversarial Moment: A woman in the audience asked if the theme of the film was “If you pursue doing something you love, good things will come to you.”

And I was like, “Uh, actually I think the lesson of this film is the exact opposite. My life took a real downward turn when I decided to be an independent filmmaker.”

And then she was like, “Well you seem pretty happy.”

And I was like, “Yeah now, at my movie release doing a Q&A. But what about next week?”

And then the woman frowned and I felt like she wanted to rebut, but she didn’t say anything else. I feel guilty for shitting on her positivity!

Programmer Cristina Caciopo, Rachel Wolther, producer Miranda Kahn and actor Jon Rudnitsky at the Q&A for The French Italian at Nitehawk.

Biggest Accomplishment Overall: I didn't get a cold, even though I went out for drinks with friends after almost every show.

Bonus Private Question: A lot of people are too shy to ask their real question in the auditorium, but given an opportunity at the afterparty will ask me what they really want to know. A lot of times these were like, “How much did you pay for [blank]?” or “Is this character/situation based on [our mutual friend]?” which, of course, I love to answer with complete honesty. (Respective Answers: “Nothing” and “Yeah, duh.”)

Also after one show, a person I did not know and who seemed a little drunk asked, “Is the guy, the boyfriend, is he gay?” I did not understand the question or which guy they meant, so I just said yes, everyone is gay in this movie.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

Related Stories

The Numb Stage of Nymphomania

Writer-director Georgia Bernstein on hypersexualization, classic erotic thrillers, In the Mood for Love and her debut feature, Night Nurse.

July 22, 2026

Nobody’s Ever Asked Me That: Abel Ferrara

The legendary writer-director opens up about everything from Buddhism and bad acid trips to social media addiction and sobriety.

The Stories We Invent Before We Have Language

Rhythm is a Dancer’s writer-director-star Lauren Caster on donor conception, language and a lifelong search for belonging.

July 17, 2026

What I Learned Directing My First Franchise Film

Kimmy Gatewood on how she thought big and gained expertise on the fly while helming her new movie, Descendants: Wicked Wonderland.

July 16, 2026

On Being Fired

Actor and singer Alicia Witt, whose David Lynch-inspired album Between Heaven and Earth is now on preorder, shares a universal experience.

July 13, 2026

When Art Finally Catches Up to You

Filmmaker Zachary Ray Sherman on making his debut feature for $10K, shelving it for eight years, and finally understanding what it was all about.

July 10, 2026