Skip to Content
Talkhouse home
Talkhouse home
Film

What Can a Story Be?

Alison McAlpine, director of the Oscar-nominated documentary short perfectly a strangeness, on pushing the boundaries of narrative.

Ever since I was a kid, I’ve sought out storytellers. Not professionals, but people who, like great actors, don’t explain themselves; they reveal a humanity that speaks to something universal.

Wherever we would go as a family I would find these storytellers and often record them; I would ask my parents, my grandparents again and again to tell me tales about our ancestors. Stories were like evocations I would rewrite and reimagine.

Alison McAlpine at La Silla observatory in the Chilean Atacama desert, during the making of perfectly a strangeness.

My first published poems were creation myths, monologues written for different characters, which were also performed by actors. Writer Alastair MacLeod, a faculty member at the Banff School of Fine Arts, called my work “film poetry” given its visual, dreamlike imagery.

perfectly a strangeness
What can a story be? Does a story need a big dramatic arc? Can a story be a gesture, a moment in time, camera and sound bringing into being what photographer Robert Frank calls “the poetry behind the surfaces of things”?

How can we, like a child or a young animal, rediscover our world as “perfectly a strangeness”?

I began my film, as I always do, with questions and challenges.

I wanted to work with texture, movement, light, shadow, reflections, sound, rhythm – no text – creating cinema that you want to touch like an exquisite painting, or a poem that you want to experience again and again, offering the viewer a space to think and imagine for themselves?

I wanted to find the authentic, uncontrived simplicity of the narrative in picture and sound, and express neither the well-known anthropomorphic view of animals, in particular donkeys, nor the familiar perception of astronomical observatories, but rather to immerse the viewer in a sensorial experience which feels animalic, fresh and unforgettable.

“Film as dream, film as music. No art passes our conscience in the way film does, and goes directly to our feelings, deep down into the dark rooms of the soul.” - Ingmar Bergman

I wrote a treatment in four movements.

    1. First light. We observe three donkeys in an unnamed desert. Desert animals are awakening. The donkeys climb a hill, spy astronomical domes, hear something unusual and decide to investigate.
    1. They enter the world of the observatory, play and explore. There is a peculiar strangeness to this new world. We sense that the observatory is watching and following the donkeys.
    1. Night falls; the observatory comes to life! The metal beasts awaken, open, turn, groan, sing during the night, chasing the stars. A sensorial, fantastic dance. We feel the interior worlds of the donkeys and the heart-soul of the observatory in conversation. Domes and telescopes churn and howl; we experience an ecstatic, tender beauty, a visual-sonic symphony we’ve never seen or heard before. There is more in the night than we can see …
    1. Epilogue: morning. The domes curl inward, sleep again. The donkeys leave the observatory.

“The project I have in mind is one which will shape itself as it proceeds and is essentially elastic.” – Robert Frank

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

Related Stories

Searching for That Missing Element

Sasha Waters on her quest for a pivotal piece of her new doc, Mary Oliver: Saved by the Beauty of the World, which hits theaters on Friday.

Nobody’s Ever Asked Me That: John Early

The beloved comedian, whose debut feature as writer-director-star, Maddie's Secret, is in theaters now, pulls back the curtain on his true self.

Never as Alone as We Think We Are

Writer-director Malin Barr on finding connection through making her debut short film Sauna Sickness, which took her to Sundance and beyond.

June 29, 2026

A Trans Lens, a Cinema of Defiance

Chase Joynt, director of the new Sarah McBride documentary State of Firsts, considers how to define the category of “trans cinema.”

June 26, 2026

Transgender / Transcendence

Writer-director Ash Mayfair on the very personal backstory to her new film Skin of Youth, the first Vietnamese fiction film starring a trans person.

June 25, 2026

Everything is Ending, Everything is Ending

Filmmaker Avalon Fast, whose latest girl horror movie CAMP opens on June 26, shares some moments from their journey.

June 24, 2026