Skip to Content
Talkhouse home
Talkhouse home
Music

Best of 2024: BUÑUEL’s Mansuetude, Like Frankenstein’s Monster, Kills Its Creator

Eugene S. Robinson on his favorite record of the year — which also happens to be his own.

9:00 AM EST on December 17, 2024

Part of this has everything to do with the whole of how, technologically speaking, music can be made these days. I can’t tell you how others do it but I can tell you how BUÑUEL does it: The songs are sent from Milan to Monte Vallier’s Ruminator Audio in San Francisco. I get a call, and after listening, in the case of Mansuetude, 173 times prior to standing in front of a mic, I do what one does when standing behind a mic.

Nothing shocking here but a few noteworthy quirks. The songs are recorded in the order in which they arrive. They are recorded in one session without a single practice because scratch vocals codify failure and who needs that? Then they are returned to Milan.

Mario Quintero from Spotlights and Timo Ellis from Netherlands mix and produce and then I listen to it ONCE before mastering. I send in notes and refuse to listen to it again until it’s in my hand, a finished product.

For intents and purposes this gets me as close as humanly possible to being able to listen to it with what I like to call “the ears of the street.” Like it wasn’t me who made it. Like it wasn’t me who was in it. This highwire act lets me know, at least privately, whether or not what we’ve done sucks.

Has it ever happened that this way of doing things has bitten me in the ass? Sure — I did a record for Dead Elephant that I had wished I had been shot in the throat rather than have heard it on release. But that being as it may: Mansuetude is not that. 

It’s dark, dingy, and dirty and for such a placid title, for want of a better word: mean. Perfectly fitting for the spirit of the age we now find ourselves.

Like the movie The Maltese Falcon was a documentary, Mansuetude manages to make all of our baser instincts seem noble in the absence of any counterbalancing weight. So every time I listen to it — and I now have listened to it, with the ears of the street, about 103 times (thanks to Apple Music stream counters, this I know) — I am surprised at the pop underpinnings to the shreds of noise, metal and post-punk that make it sound like theme songs to a late night/early morning round of crimes. All of which are bloody, all of which are unfortunate, and all of which are bloody unfortunate.

It's a beautiful sound and I can’t believe it’s me on it. And Megan O. from Couch Slut, and Jacob Bannon from Converge and Duane Denison from Jesus Lizard. Oh, what beautiful music we’ve made. This and my memoir A Walk Across Dirty Water & Straight Into Murderer’s Row make 2024 the first year I could honestly say I’d die happy after.

Though, just to be clear, I have no large scale interest in EVER dying.

And to close, runners up would be Chat Pile’s Cool World, SUMAC’s The Healer, and the Jesus Lizard’s Rack.

Related Stories

Inside the Bounce House, Part 1

How the Beastie Boys shaped Eric Slick's youth and his forthcoming album.

October 23, 2026

Lip Critic and Adult DVD Have a Sense of Humor

Bret Kaser catches up with Danny Blackburn, Greg Lonsdale, and Harry Hanson about lyrics, not shying away from their influences, and more.

October 23, 2026

Sara Quin (Tegan & Sara) Talks with Ryan Hemsworth on the Talkhouse Podcast

"What is this hellscape we've created? It's hell."

October 22, 2026

Ryan Guldemond (Mother Mother) Introduced So Faint to Each Other

The musician/producer talks to Hannah Georgas and Lyn Heinemann about their new collaborative record.

October 22, 2026

Annie DiRusso and Hannah Cole Are Rock Artists

The friends talk the “singer-songwriter” label, bands vs. solo projects, and much more.

October 21, 2026

Told Slant and Allegra Krieger Get to the Fountain

The NYC-based musicians talk songwriting, Leonard Cohen, What’s Up, and much more.

October 20, 2026